Malarkey vs. GAF: Which Roofing System Is Right for Your Home?

Who Are Malarkey and GAF?

Before diving into the details, let's start with a quick look at each brand. Whether you've just started researching your options or already have quotes in hand, understanding what makes Malarkey and GAF unique can help you decide which one is the better fit for your home.

Malarkey Roofing Products

Malarkey does not have the national presence that GAF does, but it’s quickly building a reputation for its high-performance, eco-conscious roofing materials. Their shingles are made with recycled rubber and plastics, making them more flexible and durable, especially in harsh weather. Even Malarkey’s entry-level shingles offer a Class 3 Impact Rating, and they include smog-reducing granules that help clean the air. For homeowners who value sustainability and long-term strength, Malarkey offers an innovative and long-lasting approach to roofing.

Malarkey installation photo sourced directly from their website:

GAF Roofing

GAF is one of the most well-known roofing brands in North America, with shingles sold in major retailers like Home Depot and available through nearly every roofing supplier. They're known for affordability, wide availability, and a huge range of styles and colors. With strong warranty options and decades of brand recognition, GAF appeals to homeowners looking for reliable performance at a competitive price and the peace of mind that comes with a household name.

GAF installation image sourced directly from their website:

What Categories We're Comparing Malarkey and GAF On and Why

When comparing roofing brands, it's not enough to say that one is "better." What really matters is better at what? That's why we focused on the categories that impact your roof's performance, appearance, and value over time.

What did we compare? Why did we choose these factors? And why should they matter to you as a homeowner? Below, you'll find a breakdown of each category we evaluated, and how those differences translate into real-world benefits (or drawbacks) once the roof is installed:

• Durability and Weather Resistance: This measures how well shingles withstand hail, wind, heat, and other real-world conditions. If you're in a climate that sees storms, extreme temperatures, or high humidity, durability is a necessity. Impact ratings, wind warranties, and material composition all come into play here.
• Curb Appeal and Style Options: Your roof makes up a huge part of your home's exterior. Whether you want something understated or bold, color and style variety matter, especially if you're navigating HOA rules or aiming to boost curb appeal. We considered product lines, color ranges, and the architectural impact of each brand's shingles.
• Cost and Long-Term Value: Price (and the value that comes with it) is always a key consideration when making any decision as a homeowner. We looked at each manufacturer's pricing across their various shingle ranges and what kind of performance or upgrades these costs reflect.

How Does Malarkey Compare to GAF?

While both brands offer reliable roofing solutions, they take different approaches in terms of materials, performance, and value. Let's take a closer look at how Malarkey and GAF compare across the areas that matter most to homeowners.

Durability and Weather Resistance

Your roof is your home's first line of defense against the elements, and not all shingles perform the same when it comes to weather. Let's compare how Malarkey and GAF handle real-world climate challenges like hail, wind, heat, and humidity.

Malarkey's Durability

Malarkey shingles are engineered with durability in extreme weather in mind. Even in moderate climates, the extra durability only adds to the performance. All of their available shingles hold at least a Class 3 Impact Rating, and are also more resistant to granule loss over time, which helps maintain their appearance and protective surface longer, even in harsh conditions. Here's what you're getting with their shingles:

• Strong impact resistance: All Malarkey shingles, starting with their Vista line, offer Class 4 Impact Ratings, the highest possible rating, designed to withstand large hail and flying debris without cracking. This is tested by dropping a 2-inch steel ball from 20 feet to simulate hail. A class 3 rating is tested with a 1.75-inch steel ball from 17 feet, and Malarkey's entry-level shingle (Highlander) offers this category of impact protection.
• High wind ratings: Malarkey's architectural shingles carry a standard wind warranty of up to 110 mph, and an enhanced wind warranty of up to 130 mph. This is in part due to their use of a larger, reinforced nailing zone (The Zone) and durable adhesive seals that create a strong hold in inclement weather.
• SBS-modified asphalt: Malarkey utilizes a type of asphalt modified with Styrene-Butadiene-Styrene (SBS) polymers. They even patented their own process based on this technology, known as NEX Rubberized Asphalt. Basically, this material improves flexibility in extreme cold and heat, allowing the shingle to expand and contract without cracking. This enhancement in performance makes it ideal for areas with dramatic temperature swings and improves durability, and all Malarkey shingles are constructed this way. This technology is also the reason Malarkey shingles tend to retain their granules better than other brands in similar categories.
• Advanced granule technology: Malarkey shingles use 3M smog-reducing granules, including a copper coating for algae resistance. The smog-reducing technology helps break down air pollutants using sunlight, while the copper helps protect against black streaks and other staining caused by algae, keeping your roof cleaner and looking newer for longer, especially in high-moisture and heavily shaded locations.

GAF's Durability

GAF is one of the most established and widely used roofing brands in North America, trusted by contractors and homeowners alike. Their shingles are known for their reliable performance, broad style selection, and innovative installation technology. Here's what you can expect from GAF shingles:

• Impact resistance: GAF offers Class 4 impact-resistant shingles in product lines like their Timberline AS II, built to withstand hail and flying debris using an advanced asphalt formulation. This makes them an excellent choice for homeowners in storm-prone areas seeking added protection.
• High wind protection: GAF shingles feature LayerLock Technology, which combines the common bond between overlapping shingle layers. Paired with their larger StrikeZone nailing area, this creates a strong and secure installation. When installed as part of a full GAF roofing system, products like Timberline HDZ are eligible for an unlimited wind speed warranty (a standout feature in the industry).
• Heat and UV protection: GAF's Timberline Cool Series shingles are engineered with reflective granules that help reduce heat absorption. These shingles meet Cool Roof standards and can contribute to improved energy efficiency by lowering attic temperatures, making them a smart option in warmer climates.
• Algae-resistant granules: GAF also offers shingles equipped with StainGuard and StainGuard Plus Technology. These systems use copper-infused granules to combat algae growth, protecting curb appeal and reducing the need for maintenance in humid or shaded areas.

Which Performs Better in Your Region's Climate?

Both brands offer strong performance in a range of conditions, but how well they suit your home can depend on the specific climate challenges in your area.

• Live in a hail-prone area?
  Malarkey has an edge here. With high-impact class ratings built into each of its shingle options, it's a great fit for regions that regularly experience hailstorms without needing to break the bank on a premium shingle tier.
• Struggle with algae streaks due to humidity or shade?
  Both brands address this, but Malarkey uses Scotchgard copper granules in every shingle with algae protection, while GAF reserves enhanced algae defense for select product lines.
• Need to beat the heat?
  GAF's Cool Series shingles are specifically designed to reflect sunlight and reduce attic heat. Malarkey's rubberized construction, while not a reflective product, can resist heat damage and help maintain structural integrity over time.

Curb Appeal and Style Options

While durability and performance should matter most, it's still important that your shingles look good. The right roofing material and color can enhance your home's exterior and even boost resale value. Let's compare how Malarkey and GAF stack up when it comes to style, color, and curb appeal.

Malarkey's Design Range

Malarkey offers four main shingle lines: Highlander, Vista, Legacy, and Windsor, each offering a distinct combination of performance and style.

• Highlander and Vista are Malarkey's entry and mid-level architectural shingles. They feature dimensional layering for a more attractive, textured look than traditional 3-tab shingles. Vista, in particular, offers an additional 10% thickness, upgraded granule richness, and sits at a Class 4 Impact Rating for an enhanced appearance at a great value.
• Legacy steps it up with a heavier construction and richer shadow lines, delivering more depth and a more refined appearance. These premium architectural shingles are 19% thicker than Highlander and offer a stronger warranty, but come at a higher cost.
• Windsor is Malarkey's only designer shingle. It's larger and bolder in profile, with a look that mimics wood shake roofing for added character on high-end or traditionally styled homes. Designer shingles offer superior durability and protection with a luxurious look.

While Malarkey currently offers fewer color options than some larger brands, the finishes are thoughtfully curated, with natural earth tones and bold contrasts that work well across most home styles. The emphasis is on timeless color palettes that age gracefully, and they work well for homeowners looking for balanced, long-lasting protection.

Here is an example of some of Malarkey's available color options, from the Vista shingle line:

GAF's Design Range

GAF offers a broad selection of architectural and designer shingles, with something for nearly every budget and home style. Their Timberline series is one of the most recognized in the industry, offering layered looks and modern finishes.

• Timberline NS, HDZ, and UHDZ make up GAF's core architectural lines. NS offers clean, simple lines for entry-level roof coverage. HDZ adds bold shadowing and a wider nailing zone for more accurate and secure installation, while UHDZ offers increased thickness, deeper color contrast, and enhanced durability with available Class 4 impact resistance.
• GAF's premium lines, like Camelot II, Glenwood, and Slateline, are designer shingles crafted to mimic wood shake or slate. These luxury styles offer enhanced visual depth and help elevate the look of historic, high-end, or architecturally detailed homes.

With one of the largest color and texture selections in the industry, GAF provides more flexibility for homeowners seeking specific design preferences, HOA compliance, or high-contrast finishes.

GAF stands out for its variety and visual customization, making it a top choice for homeowners prioritizing aesthetics, color-matching flexibility, or specialty textures. It's ideal for those looking to fine-tune their home's curb appeal with more tailored design options.

Here is an example of some of GAF's available color options, from the Timberline HDZ shingle line:

Which Brand's Style Is the Right Fit for Your Home?

Beyond performance, choosing the right shingle also comes down to your home's architecture and your personal style. Here's how Malarkey and GAF stack up across different home types and design needs.

• For craftsman-style, rustic, or traditional homes, Malarkey’s Windsor or Legacy shingles deliver bold texture and depth while offering serious protection.

• For newer builds or homes with modern lines, GAF’s Timberline HDZ or Cool Series shingles offer sleek dimension with flexible color choices.

• If you're part of an HOA with stricter guidelines, GAF may offer more leeway with color matching and architectural approval due to its broader selection.

• If your roof has multiple pitches or complex shapes, a well-layered architectural shingle from either brand will enhance dimension and visual interest.

Cost and Value

When you're comparing any manufacturers, it's important to consider how well your investment will hold up over time. While Malarkey and GAF offer different options and different price points, each brings a unique kind of value to the table.

Malarkey Pricing Options

Because they’re so performance-focused, Malarkey shingles tend to cost a bit more upfront, but that premium goes toward higher-quality materials, Class 3 or 4 impact ratings, and built-in sustainability features like rubberized asphalt and smog-reducing granules.

Many homeowners see the extra investment as worthwhile for the added protection and peace of mind over time. When you consider the total cost of the average roof replacement, choosing a shingle like Highlander or Vista rarely increases the quote by a significant amount, with many homeowners turning to Vista for its impressive cost-to-performance ratio.

GAF Pricing Options

As a well-established and nationally recognized brand, GAF offers more entry-level options, making it easier to stay within budget while still getting reliable performance. Products like Timberline NS provide the layered look of architectural shingles at one of the most affordable price points in the market, while Timberline HDZ offers a strong balance of value, style, and performance.

At the higher end, Timberline UHDZ includes thicker construction, advanced algae protection, and optional Class 4 impact resistance for those seeking premium protection without jumping into designer-tier pricing. Overall, GAF’s wide product range gives homeowners the flexibility to choose based on their priorities.

Which Offers Better Value in the Long Run?

The short answer is that it’s situational, based on individual needs, goals, and budget. If your priority is long-term durability, fewer repairs, and enhanced weather resistance, Malarkey may offer better value over the life of your roof while remaining an economical choice. If you’re focused on initial cost or aesthetic variety, GAF may give you more options to work within your budget, without compromising on appearance.

Here’s a quick comparison of how Malarkey and GAF compare across the criteria we’ve looked at in this article:

How to Choose the Right Roofing Brand for You

If impact resistance, granule retention, and algae protection are important for your situation, Malarkey is likely the better fit. These factors are built into every shingle tier, without adding the need to upgrade. Its use of rubberized asphalt, Class 3 or 4 impact ratings, and smog-reducing granules comes standard even on the entry-level Highlander line. It's an especially strong option for homes in hail-prone, stormy, or high-moisture climates.

If your priority is maximizing style flexibility and design options while maintaining strong durability in the higher product tiers, GAF may be the better fit. It's a great choice for homeowners who want aesthetic versatility, reliable performance, and options to fit a wider range of budgets. Their variety of product tiers gives you more control over price vs. performance.

At Happy Roofing, we work with homeowners to help them understand their unique situations and roofing options. Over the years, we've installed a variety of shingles, and we've come to know Malarkey especially well for its strength in areas like durability, sustainability, and performance in challenging weather.

If you're still comparing options and are curious whether Malarkey is worth the extra investment, take a look at our next article, Is a Malarkey Roofing System Really Worth Paying More For? It dives deeper into what you get for the price, and where it might make a meaningful difference over time. We're not trying to push you towards any decision, but since we know these products well, we've gone into more detail in order to provide you with as much information as possible so you can make a confident decision.

Want to see Malarkey system pricing for your home? Get a tailored ballpark estimate in minutes by using our instant estimator tool, no calls required.